I. Which is best? Everlywell vs. Nurx

BrandNumber of available testsPrice rangePhysician support (Y/N)Results turnaround timeLocation(at home, local lab)
Everlywell32$49 to $259Yes24 to 48 hoursAt home
Nurx3$46 to $522Yes2 to 10 business daysAt home
Which is best?EverlywellEverlywellTieEverlywellTie

Everlywell, based in Austin, Texas, was established by Julia Cheek in 2015. Nurx, founded in 2015 by Edvard Engesæth and Hans Gangeskar, has its home office in San Francisco, California. While Everlywell sells test kits for general health and wellness and reproductive issues, Nurx supplies STD test kits, herpes treatments, and a wide range of birth control options, including pills, rings, shots, and patches.

Both companies focus on consumer privacy, ensuring all test kits reach customers with discretion. Everlywell products cannot be purchased in Rhode Island, Maryland, New Jersey, and New York, while Nurx sales are limited to 29 states and the District of Columbia.

Keep reading to learn more about Everlywell and Nurx products, as well as the pros and cons of each company.

II. Pros and Cons of Everlywell

What we like about Everlywell:

  • Accepts FSA/HSA payments.
  • Discreet packaging.
  • Free consultation via video and phone.
  • Offers a wide variety of tests for general health and reproductive issues.

The drawbacks of Everlywell:

  • Accepts limited types of insurance.
  • Not available in the states of New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island, and Maryland.

III. Pros and Cons of Nurx

What we like about Nurx:

  • Accepts most insurance plans.
  • Has treatment solutions.
  • Offers numerous types of birth control.

The drawbacks of Nurx:

  • Only available in 29 states, as well as the District of Columbia.
  • Charges consultation fee even if the customer doesn’t communicate with the health staff.

IV. What do Everlywell and Nurx offer?

Everlywell and Nurx both sell at-home STD test kits. Nurx doesn’t provide single disease screening for  STD tests,  which means you need to order a bundle kit. If you require a single-pack STD test, you may want to purchase from Everlywell.

Both Everlywell and Nurx offer physician support. However, Everlywell’s physician consultations are free, while Nurx charges $15 automatically, even if you don’t make use of the service. This makes Everlywell a more attractive option if you frequently test to maintain your sexual health and don’t need to speak with a doctor.

Nurx’s prescription services let you order your birth control and purchase STD testing kits simultaneously, and delivery is always free.

In regards to the coronavirus pandemic, both companies launched COVID-19 test kits in 2020, although the kits hadn’t received official FDA approval at the time of launch.

V. What Customers Say About Everlywell

Positive reviews about Everlywell

“I absolutely loved this product and it answered a lot of my personal questions about my allergies. The results came in days before they were supposed to and I was happily surprised”

“I was very happy with the ease of taking samples and returning the samples to the lab. The results came back faster than expected. I had a follow up question after receiving results and they answered promptly.”

Negative reviews about Everlywell

“Avoid if you are looking to see if you are allergic to cats. They only test for cat dander…They need to do more research and redesign their primers.”

“My doctor said these are not reliable.”

VI. What Customers Say About Nurx

Positive reviews about Nurx

“The doctor was very helpful and answered all my questions and was able to tell me my options. Once I chose something it came quickly and discreetly in the mail. It was easy, cheap, simple, and I have access to ask questions for as long as they are providing my birth control.”

“Love this company and what they do! Getting your birth control should not be complicated. If you’ve ever had to make a doctor’s appointment to get a birth control refill, you know the annoyance. Nurx gets rid of that issue.”

Negative reviews about Nurx

“During your questionnaire it is stated that your card will not be charged until you, yourself approve the choice of medicine. Unfortunately that was not the case in my experience. Not at all pleased with NURX.”

“Ordered emergency contraceptive and the pharmacy called to tell me I had to just go to the store and buy it. Didn’t get a refund for that even though I was not helped. Ordered birth control and they sent me the wrong brand.”

VII. Everlywell vs. Nurx Bottom Line

Everlywell is a great choice if you’re seeking physician support and quick turnaround times. Everlywell sells some single STD tests, like syphilis, HIV, and hepatitis C, while Nurx only offers bundled kits that test for multiple infections.

Both brands value consumer privacy. When it comes to accessibility, neither brand is available in every state. While Everlywell is restricted in just four states, Nurx is unavailable in more than 20.  Everlywell is superior if you need convenience, since it offers numerous tests and free consultations. If you need to purchase birth control, herpes treatment, or migraine medication, Nurx is the better choice.