Disclosure: We evaluate products and services independently, but we may receive a referral fee on the services featured on this page.

I. Which is best? Everlywell vs. STDcheck

Brand Number of available tests Price range Physician support (Y/N) Results turnaround time Location (at home, local lab)
Everlywell 30+ $49 to $199
$24.99/month with membership
N Varies depending on the test At home
PlushCare 13 $24 to $258 Y 1 to 2 days Local lab
Which is best? Everlywell Tie STDcheck STDcheck Tie

Everlywell and STDcheck let you obtain medical tests online. These companies provide discreet, confidential testing options. Everlywell offers more than 30 at-home tests that are physician-reviewed, with results sent to your smartphone or tablet within days of receiving your sample.

STDcheck is focused exclusively on STD testing. The company offers more than a dozen STD tests, including test panels, that can be ordered privately online. These tests are taken at one of the company’s 4,500+ affiliated labs, and results are provided within one to two days. If you receive a positive test result, STDcheck can connect you with a physician for consultation and treatment.

Below, we compare the features and characteristics of these two medical testing companies to help you decide which one best meets your needs.

II. Pros and Cons of Everlywell

What we like about Everlywell:

  • Offers a wide selection of at-home tests.
  • No need to visit a lab for testing.
  • Results are sent directly to your device.
  • Test results are physician-reviewed.
  • Shipping is free.

The drawbacks of Everlywell:

  • Doctors aren’t available for consultation if test results are positive.
  • Test results may take longer as collected samples are mailed in.

III. Pros and Cons of STDcheck

What we like about STDcheck:

  • A physician is available for consultations if you test positive.
  • Test results are provided within one to two days.
  • All tests are FDA-approved and performed in CLIA-certified labs.

The drawbacks of STDcheck:

  • Testing must be done in the lab, so those in rural areas may have less access to testing.
  • Doesn’t offer any health tests outside of STD testing.

IV. What Do Everlywell and STDcheck Offer?

While both companies provide customers with confidential, convenient medical testing, each has a unique focus.

Everlywell’s tests are exclusively designed for at-home use. The company has STD testing kits, as well as a broad range of other medical tests, including energy and weight, sleep and stress, and COVID-19. With more than 30 tests available, and a membership that allows you to access any test for $24.99 per month, Everlywell definitely comes out on top for selection and affordability.

If it’s STD testing you’re after, STDcheck has a broader range of testing options within this niche. This company has individual STD tests, as well as a 10-test panel that can include HIV RNA early detection testing for an additional fee.

V. What Customers Say About Everlywell

Positive reviews about Everlywell

“I was skeptical about the product at first mainly because the reviews from (a) scholarly article doesn’t believe in IGg mediated sensitivity testing. I am here to tell you this is real! I have psoriasis, which by chance I found out gets drastically better when I eat a bland diet during treatments for another medical condition.”

“… serious company and good reports.”

“The process to extract blood is pretty easy and the prepaid shipping package was also convenient.”

Negative reviews about Everlywell

“Absolutely can not recommend. They’ve had my test kit back for two weeks now and I still don’t have my results.”

“The Women’s Health Test is a long process because of the timeframe during your cycle. It also hurts to draw blood using their lancet. My finger was sore for days.”

“Unfortunately a couple of doctors both told me it was a waste of money because there isn’t any scientific research to prove it means anything.”

VI. What Customers Say About STDcheck

Positive reviews about STDcheck

“The website and prices are precise and clear. Extremely easy to purchase test and make an appointment at (a) local facility.”

“This place was fast quick and simple. It’s quicker than any doctor’s office and the best part is I got my test results in less than 24 hours.”

“This website had excellent service, I got my results back in a day and couldn’t be more happy with my experience!”

Negative reviews about STDcheck

“Website states 24-48 hours for results, this is not the case. It does not include weekends, which I was initially told by staff it did.”

“This company knowingly sold me testing at a clinic near me with 1-2 day results. 30 seconds after I paid, they told me that I had to go to another clinic to get results in the timeframe they promised on their site.”

“The site is not accurate on the timing of the HIV RNA test.
It’s been 5 days and no results.”

VII. Everlywell vs. STDcheck Bottom Line

Everlywell is the clear winner if you’re after a variety of health tests at an affordable price, but Everlywell’s at-home kits may be confusing for some people. If you’re looking specifically for STD testing, STDcheck’s selection of testing options is broader and might be the better choice. You’ll also have the guidance of professional medical staff to help ensure your sample is collected correctly.