At-Home Testing Comparison: Everlywell vs. HealthLabs

Testing.com is fully supported by readers. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. You can read more about how we make money here.

Medically Reviewed by Expert Board

This page was fact checked by our expert Medical Review Board for accuracy and objectivity. Read more about our editorial policy and review process.

.
This article was last modified on
Learn more about...

Everlywell and HealthLabs both offer dozens of blood and urine tests to help people learn more about their health. Everlywell is best suited for users who feel comfortable collecting their samples at home, while HealthLabs is ideal if you prefer to let a professional handle the sample collection.

Interested in one of these test providers?

 

I. Which is best? Everlywell vs. HealthLabs

Brand Tests available Price range Physician support Results time Location Overall Rating
Everlywell 30+ $49.99 to $200 and up Yes 5 days Home 4.7/5
HealthLabs 100+ $28 to $939 Yes 1 to 2 business days Local lab 4.7/5
Which is best? HealthLabs HealthLabs Tie HealthLabs Everlywell Tie

Everlywell was founded in 2015 and currently offers more than 35 testing panels. Although Everlywell’s at-home testing is convenient, not everyone is comfortable collecting their own samples. As with Everlywell, HealthLabs has also been offering lab tests since 2015. HealthLabs makes it easy to get lab tests, but you will need to visit a local laboratory instead of collecting a sample at home.

How Everlywell and HealthLabs stack up

Compare Everlywell and HealthLabs to other popular testing brands:

Company Available tests Price range Insurance accepted Physician support Results time Location CLIA certified labs Overall rating
Everlywell 30+ $49.99 to $200 and up No Yes 5 days Home Yes 4.7 out of 5
HealthLabs 100+ $28 to $939 No Yes 1 to 2 business days Local lab Yes 4.7 out of 5
LetsGetChecked 30+ $69 to $349 No Yes 2 to 5 business days Home Yes 4.7 out of 5
MyLAB Box 40+ $32 to $499 No Yes 1 to 5 business days Home Yes 4.8 out of 5
Nurx 7 $30 to $220 Yes Yes 2 to 5 business days Home Yes 4.8 out of 5
Plushcare 30+ $99 annual membership plus visit fee; labs $5 each Yes Yes 3 to 5 business days Local lab Yes 4.7 out of 5
STDcheck 10+ $24 to $258 No Yes 1 to 2 business days Local lab Yes 4.5 out of 5

Methodology: Ratings are based on trust, cost, convenience, and comprehensive service. All test options use CLIA certified labs. Cost ratings are based on affordability compared to other testing options and insurance acceptance. Convenience is rated on the results time and testing location. Comprehensive service rates the number of available tests and the opportunity for physician support. Overall rating is an unweighted average of all rating factors.

II. Pros and Cons of Everlywell

What we like about Everlywell:

  • Tests are accredited by the College of American Pathologists.
  • Allows you to test in the comfort of your own home.
  • Offers gift cards.
  • Accepts HSA and FSA payments.

The drawbacks of Everlywell:

  • Can take up to five business days to receive results.
  • Sample collection may be difficult for some.

III. Pros and Cons of HealthLabs

What we like about HealthLabs:

  • Gives you access to thousands of labs.
  • Price-matches other lab testing companies.
  • More than 100 different tests are available.

The drawbacks of HealthLabs:

  • You must visit a local laboratory rather than collecting a sample at home.
  • Not many labs are available in rural areas, which may make it difficult to access testing services.

IV. What Do Everlywell and HealthLabs Offer?

Everlywell and HealthLabs offer many of the same tests. One of the most popular is the lipid panel, which measures your total cholesterol, triglycerides, HDL cholesterol, and LDL cholesterol. Both companies also offer tests that can help identify vitamin and mineral deficiencies, such as tests for B vitamins, vitamin D, and folic acid. Everlywell and HealthLabs test for chlamydia, gonorrhea, and other sexually transmitted infections.

While the companies measure many of the same substances, Everlywell focuses more on panels than on single tests. Therefore, you may have to purchase several individual HealthLabs tests to get the same amount of information provided by just one of Everlywell’s testing panels. Everlywell also has at-home testing kits, while HealthLabs requires you to visit a local laboratory to provide blood and/or urine samples.

Interested in one of these test providers?

 

V. What Customers Say About Everlywell

Positive reviews about Everlywell

“The blood sample was fairly easy to collect. I put my test in the mail on Monday and got my results on Friday.”

“I had emailed them my questions about the results and they sent me a very nice personalized and detailed message about my results!”

“The process to extract blood is pretty easy and the prepaid shipping package was also convenient.”

Negative reviews about Everlywell

“They’ve had my test kit back for two weeks now and I still don’t have my results.”

“A huge issue is they don’t offer phone support, only email support…”

“I followed directions exactly. The test strip did not work as it should have. I contacted the company and have not heard back.”

VI. What Customers Say About HealthLabs

Positive reviews about HealthLabs

“Always easy, fast, convenient, and a lot cheaper than if I did it with my Dr.”

“Great lab. Always quick and easy. Staff is great. Very professional.”

“HealthLabs had every test I needed and even offered me a multiple test discount for purchasing multiple tests.”

Negative reviews about HealthLabs

“My test results have been delayed for more than 3 business days. I had to make repeated calls to the customer care to inquire about my reports…”

“I put in my order and tried to cancel immediately. I didn’t want the product and they made me pay a full 20% of the cost which was about $80.”

“Slow – had to spend so much extra time trying to get my results. The customer service wasn’t great either.”

VII. Everlywell vs. HealthLabs Bottom Line

Everlywell allows you to test in the comfort of your own home, offers gift cards, and accepts FSA/HSA payments, but the collection process can be a little confusing for some tests. HealthLabs offers more than 100 tests, eliminates the need to visit your doctor to get lab orders, and price-matches other companies; however, you must visit a laboratory to give a blood or urine sample. Overall, Everlywell is a good choice if you want to collect the samples in the comfort and privacy of your own home. HealthLabs is better if you’re more concerned about having access to a wide variety of tests.